I think a lot about whether a person needs to give up or a person needs to fight. I have often thought that one of my favorite scenes in any movie is in First Knight when Sean Connery looks so defeated. He looks so beaten; he kneels and says words of surrender, concession, defeat. Then suddenly King Arthur rises up. He raises his sword to the sky, and he encourages his people to “Fight! Fight! and never surrender.” Oh, that Sean Connery moment, that beautiful Scottish accent on King Arthur (by the way, I love that.) I subconsciously believe that was the way to live—- never say die. Never surrender. For much of life that is true. Having perseverance in the face of disaster, illness, hard times— all of this is important. We cannot be sitting around giving up all the time, but there’s something deeper that I know I missed in that process.

Giving up has sounded dramatic to me at times, as if it ought to come with a great tearing loose, decisive release, a brave and shining moment of laying down everything… But most of the time, for me, it has not looked like that at all. Most of the time, surrender has looked small. It has looked reluctant. It has looked like loss. It has looked like circling the same hard thought again and again until finally, I’m tired of carrying it. It has looked nothing like triumph and more like loosening my grip by degrees.

Lately I have been seeing that one of the hardest things for me to surrender has not just been my deep sorrow itself, but my argument with God about it. If God did not do the thing I begged him to do, then somewhere in me, I decided I would not thank him for anything else either. I would not call anything mercy. I would not even give him credit when something gentle or good arrived at my door. It feels too much like letting go of my case against him. It feels disloyal to my grief. That is hard to admit, but it is true.

And that bitterness, too, is something I need to lay down. I need to lay down my refusal to notice mercy. I need to lay down my fear that gratitude will betray my grief. I don’t need to understand everything before I can receive anything good.

I am not saying everything makes sense to me. It does not. I am not saying I have tied suffering up neatly and called it resolved. I have not. I am only beginning to see that sorrow and gratitude may not be enemies after all. That what seems like unanswered prayer is real, and so is what looks like a small mercy. That love can still be true, even when answers are not.

Maybe surrender is not saying I understand. Maybe it is only saying I am willing to stop clutching what I cannot solve. Maybe it is holy ground to grieve what was not given and still give thanks for what was. It may be that part of surrender is learning to receive small mercies without feeling disloyal to my sorrow.

Dear Lord,
I lay down my refusal to notice mercy. I lay down my fear that gratitude will betray my grief. I lay down my need to understand everything before I can receive anything good. Teach me to receive small mercies without feeling disloyal to my sorrow, and please teach me that love can still be true even when answers are not.
Amen.



















